FRAMEWORK OF CRYPTOCURRENCY 

“Legal aspects for regulating cryptocurrency in India” 

Introduction to Cryptocurrency

Cryptocurrency is a digital, decentralized form of currency that uses cryptography for security and operates outside of government and bank control. The core technology behind cryptocurrency is the blockchain, a public ledger of all transactions that makes it difficult to counterfeit or double-spend. While cryptocurrencies can be used as a medium of exchange for purchasing goods and services from certain vendors, their acceptance is still evolving. Some people also view cryptocurrencies as an investment asset, although their value can be highly volatile. The first and most well-known cryptocurrency is Bitcoin, which has been followed by numerous other cryptocurrencies, each with unique features and applications.

Understanding Cryptocurrency

To better understand cryptocurrency, imagine a giant digital spreadsheet accessible to everyone. This spreadsheet records all transactions of a particular digital currency. Cryptography ensures the security and accuracy of these transactions. Unlike traditional money held by banks, this digital currency isn't controlled by a single authority but operates on a decentralized network of computers. This decentralized nature is one of the key features that differentiate cryptocurrencies from traditional fiat currencies.

Uses of Cryptocurrency

Investment Potential

Speculative Investment

In India, cryptocurrencies are often seen as a speculative investment. Investors hope that the value of cryptocurrencies will increase over time, providing significant returns. However, the market is highly volatile, and investing in cryptocurrencies carries substantial risks. Price fluctuations can be extreme, leading to potential significant financial losses.

Tax Implications

The Indian government introduced a 30% tax on income from virtual digital assets (VDAs) in the 2022 Union Budget. This indicates that the government considers cryptocurrencies as an asset class for taxation purposes. However, this taxation does not necessarily legitimize cryptocurrencies as an investment or a currency. It merely recognizes the income generated from cryptocurrency trading for tax purposes.

Limited Adoption by Businesses

Merchant Acceptance

Due to the lack of regulations and the absence of legal tender status, very few businesses in India accept cryptocurrencies as a form of payment. The regulatory uncertainty surrounding cryptocurrencies deters businesses from integrating them into their payment systems.

Remittances

There have been discussions about the potential use of cryptocurrencies for remittances—sending money abroad. However, this practice has not become mainstream in India. Traditional banking systems and established remittance services continue to dominate the market.

Alternative Uses

Borderless Transactions

Cryptocurrencies can facilitate international transactions, bypassing traditional banking systems. This can be particularly useful in scenarios where conventional banking channels are slow, expensive, or unreliable. However, the anonymity associated with cryptocurrency transactions raises concerns about money laundering and other illicit activities.

Decentralized Finance (DeFi)

Decentralized Finance (DeFi) applications built on blockchain technology offer an alternative financial system without intermediaries like banks. In India, a limited number of individuals are exploring DeFi applications. While DeFi presents innovative financial solutions, it also carries risks, including smart contract vulnerabilities and regulatory uncertainty.

Legal Regulations

The legal framework for cryptocurrency in India is complex and evolving. There is no single, definitive law governing cryptocurrencies, leading to a dynamic regulatory environment.

No Legal Tender Status

Cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin are not recognized as legal tender in India. This means they cannot be used for everyday transactions like buying groceries or paying for services. The legal tender status is reserved for the Indian Rupee (INR), issued and regulated by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI).

RBI Circular (2018)

In 2018, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) issued a circular prohibiting banks and other financial institutions from dealing with cryptocurrencies. This ban included activities such as opening accounts for crypto exchanges or facilitating cryptocurrency transactions. The RBI cited concerns about consumer protection, market integrity, and financial stability.

Government Stance

The Indian government has expressed concerns about the potential risks associated with cryptocurrencies, such as money laundering and terror financing. While discussions and proposals for regulatory frameworks have been ongoing, concrete legislation has not yet been implemented. The government's cautious approach reflects the need to balance innovation with risk management.

Taxation of Crypto

The 2022 Union Budget introduced a 30% tax on income from virtual digital assets (VDAs), including cryptocurrencies. Additionally, a 1% TDS (Tax Deducted at Source) applies to payments exceeding a specific limit made for purchasing crypto assets. This taxation framework suggests that the government views cryptocurrencies as an asset class subject to income tax, but it does not necessarily confer legal status or regulatory clarity.

Proposed Cryptocurrency Bill (2021)

In 2021, the Indian government introduced a draft bill titled "The Cryptocurrency and Regulation of Official Digital Currency Bill." This bill proposed a ban on all private cryptocurrencies and aimed to create a framework for a central bank digital currency (CBDC) issued by the RBI. The bill has not yet been passed, and its future remains uncertain.

Current Scenario

In the absence of clear regulations, the cryptocurrency market in India operates in a grey area. Cryptocurrency exchanges exist and function, but they operate outside the traditional banking system, posing risks for investors. The lack of regulatory clarity creates an environment of uncertainty for both consumers and businesses.

Challenges Related to Cryptocurrency

Regulation

Cryptocurrency regulations are still being developed around the world, including in India. The lack of a consistent regulatory framework creates uncertainty for investors and businesses. A clear regulatory environment is essential for fostering innovation while protecting consumers and maintaining financial stability.

Security Risks

Cryptocurrency exchanges and wallets can be vulnerable to hacking and other security breaches. High-profile hacking incidents have resulted in significant financial losses for investors. Ensuring robust security measures is crucial for the sustainability of the cryptocurrency ecosystem.

Environmental Impact

The process of creating some cryptocurrencies, known as mining, can consume a large amount of energy. Bitcoin mining, in particular, has been criticized for its environmental impact due to the high energy consumption required for the proof-of-work consensus mechanism.

Investment Risks

Due to the lack of regulations, there is no investor protection framework for cryptocurrency investments in India. This exposes investors to potential scams, hacking, and market volatility. The absence of regulatory oversight increases the risk of fraud and financial loss.

Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Know Your Customer (KYC) Concerns

Without proper regulations, cryptocurrencies can be attractive for money laundering or other illegal activities. Implementing robust AML and KYC procedures is essential to prevent misuse of cryptocurrencies for illicit purposes.

Consumer Protection

In the absence of clear guidelines, there is no established mechanism to address consumer grievances related to cryptocurrency transactions. Consumer protection is a critical aspect that needs to be addressed to build trust in the cryptocurrency market.

Future Prospects

The Indian government is expected to continue exploring regulatory measures concerning the cryptocurrency realm. The specific approach, whether involving a comprehensive prohibition, an authorization system, or a blend of both, is yet to be determined. The future of cryptocurrency regulation in India will likely be shaped by the need to balance innovation with consumer protection and financial stability.

The adoption of cryptocurrency is being driven by members of Generation Z and millennials. These younger generations are attracted to the space due to their skepticism of traditional banks and financial institutions, the excitement of volatile price movements, and the accessibility of digital technology and information. Peer-to-peer (P2P) platforms have significantly contributed to the growth of cryptocurrency adoption among the tech-savvy generation. Additionally, the increasing mainstream acceptance of cryptocurrency is expected to fuel its future penetration into more niche segments of the population.

Case Study: Cryptocurrency Regulation in India

Background

In 2018, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) issued a circular prohibiting banks from dealing with individuals or businesses involved in cryptocurrency transactions. This ban effectively cut off the banking support for cryptocurrency exchanges and traders, creating a significant barrier for the cryptocurrency market in India.

Supreme Court Ruling

In March 2020, the Supreme Court of India lifted the RBI's ban on cryptocurrency trading. The court ruled that the RBI's circular was disproportionate and violated the right to carry out any occupation, trade, or business under Article 19(1)(g) of the Indian Constitution. This landmark judgment was seen as a victory for the cryptocurrency community in India, allowing exchanges to reopen bank accounts and resume operations.

Impact on the Market

Following the Supreme Court's decision, there was a resurgence of interest in cryptocurrencies in India. Several cryptocurrency exchanges reported a significant increase in trading volumes and user registrations. The ruling provided a much-needed boost to the market, fostering a more positive sentiment among investors and businesses.

Government's Response

Despite the Supreme Court's ruling, the Indian government remained cautious about cryptocurrencies. In 2021, the government proposed the "Cryptocurrency and Regulation of Official Digital Currency Bill," which aimed to ban private cryptocurrencies and establish a framework for a central bank digital currency (CBDC). The proposed bill created uncertainty and concern within the cryptocurrency community.

Current Scenario

As of 2023, the Indian government has not yet passed the proposed cryptocurrency bill. The regulatory environment remains unclear, with cryptocurrency exchanges operating in a legal grey area. The introduction of a 30% tax on income from virtual digital assets in the 2022 Union Budget indicates the government's intent to regulate the market. However, comprehensive regulations are still awaited.

Lessons Learned

The case of cryptocurrency regulation in India highlights the challenges of balancing innovation with risk management. The lifting of the RBI ban demonstrated the potential for judicial intervention to protect economic rights. However, the ongoing regulatory uncertainty underscores the need for a clear and consistent regulatory framework to ensure the sustainable growth of the cryptocurrency market.

Conclusion

Cryptocurrency regulations in India are complex and subject to change. The primary use of cryptocurrency in India remains speculative investment, with limited adoption for everyday transactions. Investors considering cryptocurrencies should exercise caution, invest only what they can afford to lose, and use reputable exchanges. Independent research and consultation with a financial advisor are essential before making any investment decisions.

The mainstream adoption of cryptocurrency in India is hindered by the lack of regulations and legal tender status. It is crucial to be aware of the associated risks, including market volatility, security threats, and regulatory uncertainties. As the Indian government continues to explore regulatory measures, the future of cryptocurrency in India will depend on the balance between fostering innovation and ensuring consumer protection and financial stability.

References

• Moodalagiri, S. (2022, May 5). The evolution of cryptocurrencies in India and what the future looks like. Times of India Blog. Times of India Blog
• Education, J. (2024, April 17). Cryptocurrency in the Indian economy. Jaro Education. Jaro Education
• Freeman Law. (2023, December 15). India - Cryptocurrency laws and regulation - Freeman Law. Freeman Law
• Choice - stock broker & full service stock brokerage firm in India. (n.d.). Choice India
• Patel, E. (2023, December 4). The future of crypto: Top trends for 2024. The Economic Times. The Economic Times

Unlock the Potential of Legal Expertise with LegalMantra.net - Your Trusted Legal Consultancy Partner”

Article Compiled by:-

~Sura Anjana Srimayi

(LegalMantra.net Team)

Disclaimer: Every effort has been made to avoid errors or omissions in this material in spite of this, errors may creep in. Any mistake, error or discrepancy noted may be brought to our notice which shall be taken care of in the next edition In no event the author shall be liable for any direct indirect, special or incidental damage resulting from or arising out of or in connection with the use of this information Many sources have been considered including Newspapers, Journals, Bare Acts, Case Materials , Charted Secretary, Research Papers etc.

Print